73 Comments
User's avatar
Claire Pannukakku's avatar

The Boys series deserves an honourable mention. It’s super heroes behaving badly and lots of very wrong things happening to the human body. It’s also available in highly (un) digestible hourly chunks.

Expand full comment
Michael Marshall Smith's avatar

Ah, I did hear good things about that, actually. Thank you for the reminder...

Expand full comment
Peter Coleborn's avatar

Hi Mike. The Boys is definitely worth a watch. As is The Umbrella Academy. As much as I "enjoy" superhero movies (some of them), your piece is spot on.

Expand full comment
Michael Marshall Smith's avatar

Yes, I did quite enjoy UA, actually...

Expand full comment
Sean Sakamoto's avatar

Rule 32: No matter how typical a superhero movie is (and they’re all typical) fans will tell you that you have to see it because it’s different from the others. This is never true.

Expand full comment
Kim's avatar

Nooooo

Expand full comment
Graham Lee's avatar

At risk of pointy stick, the first Iron Man was 'the same old bollocks' but the bollocks had yet to be firmly established. I think because of that, it nearly gets away with it. At least you don't have to try to remember all the mind-numbing detail of the previous 17 loosely-tied plots to know what the frack is going on.

I'll second 'The Boys' as a good bit of anti-superhero nonsense, though by season three it's getting a bit tired. It really only has one surprise - 'not all superheroes are good' & that's blown early doors.

As for the rest, I've seen them all… or half of them. I'm usually fast asleep by act three when the big battle comes up. [Advantage of being a sound engineer, I have some very clever compressors strapped to my HTPC outputs so the explosions don't wake me or the neighbours up, but I can still hear what they say when they whisper.]

… and do keep teaching the Americans the usages of such as bollocks, otherwise they're missing out on some of life's most succinct damning terminology;)

Expand full comment
Michael Marshall Smith's avatar

Bollocks, The New Superhero!

Expand full comment
Graham Lee's avatar

…and his sidekick, Cobblers the wonder boy, ably assisted by Scrotum the wrinkled retainer [with credit to Viv Stanshall].

Expand full comment
Donald (no not that one)'s avatar

If you turn the sound up enough to hear the mumbled monologue, the action scenes will rupture your eardrums.

Expand full comment
Roger Gray's avatar

OK mate get your pointy stick sharpening implement ready because I'm going to recommend you a supe movie. Captain America: The Winter Soldier! I honestly think it's a bloody good movie!

Expand full comment
Michael Marshall Smith's avatar

Hmm. Okay. I'll look it out, as — for reasons I don't quite understand — I generally trust your taste.

Expand full comment
Roger Gray's avatar

Could it be I've lived most of my life immersed in cinema from around the world, did my undergrad degree in film, worked for the Hollywood studios for 15 years and have written 9 feature scripts or are you just a weee bit crazy :-)

Expand full comment
Stuart Mackenzie's avatar

Unbreakable.

Expand full comment
Michael Marshall Smith's avatar

I'd see that as a meta example, but yes: THAT was a good movie.

Expand full comment
Dave Graham's avatar

See also phenomenal quantities of property damage

Expand full comment
Marion Pitman's avatar

Oh I do like that! and why do ALL movies these days go on for hours and hours and hours... Gone with the Wind had an interval

Expand full comment
Michael Marshall Smith's avatar

They’re ENDLESS

Expand full comment
Marion Pitman's avatar

And to be honest, if you take out the CGI and leave the acting, they're a reasonable length

Expand full comment
Paula Grainger's avatar

The Incredibles, though...

Expand full comment
Michael Marshall Smith's avatar

That's a meta movie, though ;-)

Expand full comment
Matt Brolly's avatar

It all went downhill after the first two Superman movies(Christopher Reeve, of course)

Expand full comment
Trev Ralph's avatar

My faves are the meta types already mentioned and I liked the premise of Hancock, but I’m not sure they pulled it off that well. If you watch it, a blunt stick might be in order 😬

Expand full comment
Michael Marshall Smith's avatar

I shall consider that a semi-recommendation ;-)

Expand full comment
Brian Hagman's avatar

This is the type of movie where they leave logic and reason at the door and I'm all for it. I don't mind a ridiculous thrill ride. Also I've been trying to climb on walls since I was 8.

Expand full comment
Kim's avatar

I tried to fly. I still think I did it.

Expand full comment
Brian Hagman's avatar

I'm sure you did. I stuck to the wall once. Now those shorts are covered in paint.

Expand full comment
Brian Mcgowan's avatar

why are they so popular?

Expand full comment
Michael Marshall Smith's avatar

I honestly don't know. A simple formula over and over again, maybe... like comfort food. And there's a place for that... these movies just don't do it for me though.

Expand full comment
R.Lee's avatar

Look no further than Doom Patrol for an oddly compelling antidote. Emphasis on “oddly”.

Expand full comment
Francine Hibiscus's avatar

I never read superhero comics when I was a kid, and aside from the glorious Adam West Batman, didn't care about the stories one bit. As an adult... I still don't care! but I do enjoy comedy stuff like Deadpool and Guardians of the Galaxy.

I was utterly blown away by Black Panther, just a gorgeous piece of work. I think my enjoyment of the marvel movies has to do with the actors, rather than the movies themselves.

Expand full comment
Michael Marshall Smith's avatar

Friend of mine keeps badgering me to see DEADPOOL... haven't got round to it yet :-)

Expand full comment
Francine Hibiscus's avatar

It has that sassy sarcastic breaking the fourth wall kind of charm. And Morena Baccarin!

Expand full comment
Grantus Maximus's avatar

Condorman, Flash Gordon, Manimal...

They just don't make them that bad anymore, but at least they had humour!

Expand full comment